不同窗口下中值滤波与加权滤波方法效果分析Performance of median filtering and weighted average filtering under different window sizes
牛冲
摘要(Abstract):
为了探究中值滤波与加权滤波方法对测深数据粗差的处理效果,该文以单波束测深数据为例,对中值滤波和加权滤波在不同大小滤波窗口的测深数据处理效果进行对比分析。实验结果表明,中值滤波不论在地形起伏变化较快的区域,还是在少量、断点不连续的区域以及大量、断点连续的区域,均具有较好的滤波效果,且在5窗口时效果最佳;而加权滤波在地形起伏变化较快的区域以及少量、断点不连续的区域处理效果明显,且在3窗口时效果最佳,但中值滤波效果更优,而在大量、断点连续的区域加权滤波效果明显较差,建议优先考虑中值滤波方法。
关键词(KeyWords): 单波束测深;粗差;中值滤波;加权滤波;滤波窗口
基金项目(Foundation): 山东省地质测绘院科技创新发展基金项目(chyky201902)
作者(Author): 牛冲
DOI: 10.16251/j.cnki.1009-2307.2021.08.004
参考文献(References):
- [1]梁武南,杨保岑,舒晓明.一体化单波束精密测深方法研究[J].测绘与空间地理信息,2013,36(3):27-29.(LIANG Wunan,YANG Baocen,SHU Xiaoming.Study on precise integrated sounding of single beam system[J].Geomatics&Spatial Information Technology,2013,36(3):27-29.)
- [2]李明叁,张杰,严怀志,等.序统计滤波估计检测海洋测深异常数据[J].海洋测绘,2007,27(1):7-11.(LIMingsan,ZHANG Jie,YAN Huaizhi,et al.Order statistics filtering for detecting outliers in depth data along a sounding line[J].Hydrographic Surveying and Charting,2007,27(1):7-11.)
- [3]黄辰虎,陆秀平,欧阳永忠,等.多波束水深测量误差源分析与成果质量评定[J].海洋测绘,2014,34(2):1-6.(HUANG Chenhu,LU Xiuping,OUYANG Yongzhong,et al.Analysis of error source and quality assessment about multibeam sounding product[J].Hydrographic Surveying and Charting,2014,34(2):1-6.)
- [4]袁建飞.多波束测深系统水下地形测量声速改正研究[J].测绘与空间地理信息,2019,42(12):211-213.(YUAN Jianfei.Research on sound velocity correction of underwater topography measurement by multibeam sounding system[J].Geomatics&Spatial Information Technology,2019,42(12):211-213.)
- [5]HOU T H,HUFF L C,MAYER L A.Automatic detection of outliers in multibeam echo sounding data[C]∥US Hydrographic Conference 2001.Norfolk,VA:Hydrographic Society of America,2001.
- [6]HUANG T,YANG G,TANG G.A fast two dimensional median filtering algorithm[J].IEEETransactions on Acoustics Speech&Signal Processing,1979,27(1):13-18.
- [7]CALDER B R,WELLS D E.CUBE user’s manual[M].Durham,NH:University of New Hampshire,2007.
- [8]MEGURO M,TAGUCHI A,HAMADA N.Data dependent weighted average filtering for image sequence restoration[J].Electronics and Communications in Japan,2001,84(4):1-10.
- [9]林珲,吴立新,方兆宝,等.水深测量的误差因子分析[J].海洋测绘,2005,25(2):1-5.(LIN Hui,WULixin,FANG Zhaobao,et al.Analysis for error factor in sounding[J].Hydrographic Surveying and Charting,2005,25(2):1-5.)
- [10]BJRKE J T,NILSEN S.Fast trend extraction and identification of spikes in bathymetric data[J].Computers&Geosciences,2009,35(6):1061-1071.
- [11]CALDER B R,MAYER L A.Automatic processing of high rate,high-density multibeam echosounder data[J].Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems,2003,4(6):53-68.
- [12]刘力,孙再刚,简波,等.单波束测深仪水深粗差检测与修正新算法及其效果[J].水运工程,2014(11):55-59.(LIU Li,SUN Zaigang,JIAN Bo,et al.Performance of novel algorithm of gross error detection and correction of water depth of single beam bathymeter[J].Port&Waterway Engineering,2014(11):55-59.)
- [13]汪诗奇,张红梅,赵建虎.多波束水体影像中噪声干扰的削弱方法研究[J].武汉大学学报(信息科学版),2019,44(4):539-545.(WANG Shiqi,ZHANG Hongmei,ZHAO Jianhu.Reduction of noise interference in multibeam water column image[J].Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2019,44(4):539-545.)
- [14]张红梅,赵建虎.河床演变野外采集源数据滤波方法研究[J].泥沙研究,2004(3):34-40.(ZHANG Hongmei,ZHAO Jianhu.Research on filter methods for field data of riverbed evolution[J].Journal of Sediment Research,2004(3):34-40.)
- [15]胡光海,周兴华.趋势面分析在水深测量数据处理中的应用[J].测绘工程,2004,13(3):23-25.(HU Guanghai,ZHOU Xinghua.Application of trend surface analysis in process data processing of water depth[J].Engineering of Surveying and Mapping,2004,13(3):23-25.)
- [16]黄贤源,隋立芬,翟国君,等.利用Bayes估计进行多波束测深异常数据探测[J].武汉大学学报(信息科学版),2010,35(2):168-171.(HUANG Xianyuan,SUILifen,ZHAI Guojun,et al.Outliers detection of multibeam data based on Bayes estimation[J].Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2010,35(2):168-171.)
- [17]黄谟涛,翟国君,欧阳永忠,等.多波束与单波束测深数据的融合处理技术[J].测绘学报,2001,30(4):299-303.(HUANG Motao,ZHAI Guojun,OUYANG Yongzhong,et al.Data fusion technique for single beam and multibeam echosoundings[J].Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica,2001,30(4):299-303.)
- [18]王德刚,叶银灿.CUBE算法及其在多波束数据处理中的应用[J].海洋学研究,2008,26(2):82-88.(WANGDegang,YE Yincan.The theory of CUBE algorithm and its application in the processing of multi-beam data[J].Journal of Marine Science,2008,26(2):82-88.)
- [19]王海栋,柴洪洲.基于CUBE算法的多波束测深数据自动处理研究[J].海洋通报,2011,30(3):246-251.(WANG Haidong,CHAI Hongzhou.Research on multibeam bathymetry data automatic processing based on CUBE algorithm[J].Marine Science Bulletin,2011,30(3):246-251.)
- [20]王君婷,王振杰.单波束无验潮测深数据滤波方法[J].工程勘察,2018,46(3):48-52,74.(WANG Junting,WANG Zhenjie.The filtering method of single beam sounding data without tidal observation[J].Geotechnical Investigation&Surveying,2018,46(3):48-52,74.)
- [21]张兴伟,潘国富,张济博.基于中值滤波加权修正的多波束声呐测深数据趋势面滤波方法[J].海洋科学,2018,42(7):32-39.(ZHANG Xingwei,PAN Guofu,ZHANGJibo.Trend surface filtering method for multibeam sonar echosounding data based on median filter weighed correction[J].Marine Sciences,2018,42(7):32-39.)
- [22]张文祥,王健,李尊辉,等.抗差估计在无验潮单波束测深异常数据检测中的应用[J].勘察科学技术,2018(5):40-44.(ZHANG Wenxiang,WANG Jian,LI Zunhui,et al.Application of robust estimation to detecting abnormal data of single beam sounding without tide test[J].Site Investigation Science and Technology,2018(5):40-44.)
- [23]陈家益,黄楠,熊刚强,等.基于置信区间的自适应加权均值滤波算法[J].南京理工大学学报,2017,41(3):307-312.(CHEN Jiayi,HUANG Nan,XIONG Gangqiang,et al.Adaptive weighted mean filtering algorithm based on confidence interval[J].Journal of Nanjing University of Science and Technology,2017,41(3):307-312.)
- [24]沈德海,侯建,鄂旭,等.基于米字型子窗口中值加权的滤波算法[J].计算机技术与发展,2017,27(9):78-81.(SHEN Dehai,HOU Jian,E Xu,et al.Median weighted filtering algorithm based on UK-flag shaped subwindows[J].Computer Technology and Development,2017,27(9):78-81.)